skip navigation

2021 Newcomer of the Year finalists announced

By WBC staff, 07/08/21, 10:30AM CDT


Kenosha St. Joseph sophomore Brady Davidson swings during the Division 3 state championship against Coleman on June 29 in Grand Chute.

The 2021 high school season is in the books, a welcome statement following the absence of a season in 2020.

With baseball players back out on the field in the Badger State, several made their case as some of the top talent in the state. Wisconsin Baseball Central will recognize those athletes again this year with our postseason awards.

First up is the Newcomer of the Year, to be followed by the Pitcher of the Year, Player of the Year and All-Wisconsin teams.

The Newcomer of the Year honor goes to the player who had the best yearlong performance in his first season of significant varsity playing time. Only freshmen and sophomores are eligible to win the award.

Newcomer of the Year was first introduced in 2017, with Aquinas' Jess Ondell winning the inaugural award. West De Pere's Cameron Dupont won the 2018 award, and Eau Claire North's Gabriel Richardson was the 2019 winner.

Here are the 10 finalists for the 2021 Wisconsin Baseball Central Newcomer of the Year award, listed alphabetically by last name.

Alex Alicea, St. Thomas More sophomore infielder

Alicea is one of the top sophomores in the Midwest, and he proved it in his debut varsity season. The infielder batted .515 from the top of the Cavaliers' lineup, ripping seven doubles, four triples and two homers. The Louisville commit also stole 22 bases.

Tyler Butina, Jefferson sophomore infielder

Butina was a major factor in the Eagles earning a silver trophy as the Division 2 state runner-up. The sophomore sensation batted .462 with an eye-popping 27 extra-base hits and 43 RBIs. He knocked 20 doubles, two triples and five home runs.

Brady Davidson, Kenosha St. Joseph sophomore infielder

Davidson helped carry a deep Lancers team to the Division 3 state title. The infielder posted a .464 batting average to go along with nine doubles, four triples and 39 RBIs for the champs.

Sam Erickson, Hudson freshman outfielder

Erickson emerged as arguably the top freshman in the state for the Big Rivers Conference champion Raiders. The outfielder batted .436 with six doubles, two home runs and 14 RBIs, serving as a key cog on an impressive team despite his youth.

Cal Fisher, Deerfield sophomore infielder

Fisher showed why he picked up an offer from Notre Dame, dazzling in his first varsity season. The Fighting Irish commit hit .486 with eight doubles, one triple and 10 home runs for the Demons. The infielder drove in 40 runs.

Evan Gustafson, Altoona sophomore utility

On a team full of youth, Gustafson stood out as the best for the Rails. He earned Western Cloverbelt Conference player of the year honors by shining at the plate and on the mound. Offensively, he hit .449 with nine doubles, three triples, five homers and 32 RBIs. As a pitcher, he posted a 4-0 record and 1.46 ERA.

Boston Halloran, Franklin sophomore infielder

The Sabers earned a share of the Southeast Conference title, and Halloran's play was a big reason why. He posted a .464 batting average with 16 doubles. He drove in 14 runs.

Jackson Hunley, Sun Prairie sophomore pitcher

Hunley emerged as a pivotal piece in the Cardinals' push to the Division 1 state title, particularly starring at the state tournament. For the year, he went 7-0 with a 1.61 ERA in 43.1 innings of work.

Cole Selvig, Regis sophomore pitcher

Selvig is rated among the top sophomores in the region, and is already committed to Texas. He helped take his team to the state tournament in Division 3 this spring, posting a 7-1 record and a 1.43 ERA. In 53.2 innings, he struck out 112 batters — good for an average of about two per inning.

Zach Wolfram, Menomonee Falls sophomore pitcher

Wolfram was an important part of the Phoenix's impressive pitching staff that went on a run to the Division 1 state semifinals. He shined in that semifinal game, holding eventual state champion Sun Prairie to one run on three hits in 5.2 innings of work. For the year, he was 7-1 with a 0.54 ERA in 51.1 innings.

More News

2021 All-Wisconsin Teams

By WBC staff 07/22/2021, 8:00am CDT

Webster's Washburn named Player of the Year

By WBC staff 07/17/2021, 11:00am CDT

2021 Player of the Year finalists announced

By WBC staff 07/16/2021, 12:45pm CDT

St. Croix Falls' Lessman named Pitcher of the Year

By WBC staff 07/14/2021, 3:45pm CDT

2021 Pitcher of the Year finalists announced

By WBC staff 07/13/2021, 8:45am CDT

2021 Legion Rankings: First Edition

By WBC staff 07/12/2021, 10:30am CDT

Jefferson's Butina named Newcomer of the Year

By WBC staff 07/09/2021, 9:00am CDT

Sun Prairie adds to championship haul

By WBC staff 07/01/2021, 10:15pm CDT

Denmark wins first state title

By WBC staff 06/30/2021, 9:30pm CDT

Kenosha St. Joseph wins D3 state title

By WBC staff 06/29/2021, 11:00pm CDT